I have a band signed to Columbia Records, a band signed to Sunday Best, and I work out of the office of Wichita Recordings. Though I’ve not really worked with Sunday Best very much yet, I like to think that working with these three gives me the potential for quite a broad spectrum of different sizes of label knowledge.
I like most of the people at Columbia immensely, indeed I can’t think of anyone there I don’t like. But I’m constantly amazed at the behemoth that is Sony BMG’s incompetence and inconsistency, forged not via the people who work there but merely by the size and general backwards-ness of the company – mostly, I think, via the ‘company policy’ brought over from the US. Added to that is the fact that my music taste is a little leftfield and therefore I think that quite a few of their recent signings are, well, a bit shit. I like pop hits immensely, and to prove it I’ve been listening to The Lexicon of Love all week, but I can’t be doing with rubbish pop songs that are pretending to be cool. Step forward, Ali Love!
Wichita, on the other hand, are as far as I can tell pretty much everything I like in a label. Brilliant bands of varied genre and degrees of success (even their two most commercially successful acts, The Cribs and Bloc Party, are totally different to each other musically – add Euros Childs, The Bronx and Los Campesinos! to the clan, and it’s an eclectic stable), lots of amazing licensed records from the US, Canada and Europe (this week I have been enjoying Menomena, and on Monday I went to see Arts & Crafts’ Stars at the Scala); an office with lots of boxes and a comfy sofa; the right level of cynicism and loveliness combined in the people that work there; Mark Bowen at the helm (an unfair advantage, given that there is only one MB, but an advantage it remains). Wichita are indie but not snobs about it, and they are certainly not evil. Sony BMG quite possibly are.
It’s for the reasons outlined above that I feel quite pleased that Peter Bjorn and John find themselves sitting at number 20 in the top 40, a few places down from last week’s #13. Ali Love, as far as I can see, isn’t even in the top 75. This feels like justice in the battle between good vs evil. While I want Columbia’s releases to go well for the sake of my band, not to mention the marketing and A&R teams who often work similar bands, there is a point that my magnanimousness stops. I can’t help but feel that while the label is signing dross like Ali Love then it possibly deserves everything that it (doesn’t) get, and while Wichita continues to put out great records with integrity and none of that sueing downloaders lark, then their success is to be celebrated.